The Supreme Court of India on November 19, 2026, declined a plea seeking to extend the one-year deemed practice benefit for civil judge examinations to law graduates of the 2026 batch.

Scope of Deemed Practice Under Bhumika Trust

A Bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, and Justice V. Mohana heard a Special Leave Petition filed by a 2026 law graduate challenging eligibility hurdles under recruitment norms for judicial service.

Key Observations and Legal Principles

  • Transitional Relaxation Limited to 2025 Batch: The Court clarified that the one-year deemed practice fiction under Bhumika Trust accounted for the gap between the 2025 decision and the August 2026 revised ruling, during which 2025 graduates were presumed to have gained practical exposure in chambers, law offices, or courts.
  • Value of Practical Experience: The Bench observed that extending the deeming fiction to newly enrolled 2026 graduates would go too far, encouraging them to spend a year working in offices, chambers, or courts to gain practical grounding before entering judicial service.

The Supreme Court declined to extend the one-year deemed practice exemption to 2026 graduates.