Madhya Pradesh High Court Slams State Government for Citing AI-Generated Fake Supreme Court Judgment

The Madhya Pradesh High Court has strongly criticised the State Government for relying on a non-existent Supreme Court judgment in its legal submissions, observing that the fabricated case citation appeared to have resulted from the blind use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools while drafting court pleadings.

Justice Vivek Kumar Singh made the observations while deciding a writ petition filed by former police officer Piyush Mani Tiwari, who challenged his dismissal from service without a regular departmental inquiry. In its order dated November 17, 2026, the Court set aside the dismissal and directed the State Government to reinstate the officer forthwith, while granting liberty to initiate a regular departmental inquiry in accordance with law.

State Government Relied on a Non-Existent Supreme Court Judgment

During the proceedings, the State Government relied on a purported Supreme Court judgment titled State of Andhra Pradesh v. S.S. Mohammad Nisar, cited as (2008) 5 SCC 230. The State invoked the alleged ruling to support its argument that a High Court cannot reappreciate evidence while exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution.

However, the High Court found that no Supreme Court judgment bearing that case title existed. It further noted that the citation actually belonged to Sidhartha Vashisht alias Manu Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi), a completely unrelated criminal matter concerning the suspension of a sentence during an appeal.

The Court observed that the respondents had apparently resorted blindly to AI tools while preparing their pleadings, resulting in a fabricated case name being linked to an unrelated legal citation.

High Court Calls Unverified AI-Generated Citations Irresponsible

Taking serious exception to the drafting of the State's reply, the Court emphasised that pleadings filed before a Constitutional Court are solemn documents and must be prepared with due professional care.

The Bench cautioned that inserting fictitious judicial precedents without verifying their authenticity wastes valuable judicial time and borders on actively misleading the Court.

The Court strictly cautioned the State machinery against such reckless practices and emphasised the responsibility of legal professionals to independently verify every legal proposition and judicial citation before placing them on record.

Advocate General's Office Directed to Ensure Verification

The High Court stressed that the office of the Advocate General must ensure that all legal propositions and case citations are meticulously verified by drafting counsel before affidavits are sworn and filed before the Court.

A copy of the order was directed to be forwarded to the State's Law Department and the Advocate General for appropriate attention.

Dismissal Set Aside for Violation of Article 311

The underlying dispute concerned Piyush Mani Tiwari, a former Acting Sub-Inspector posted at the State Situation Room of the Special Branch Police Headquarters in Bhopal. Following a complaint of alleged indecent behaviour made by a woman cleaner on May 26, 2024, he was suspended on the same day and dismissed from service on May 27, 2024, without a regular departmental inquiry.

The State defended its decision by invoking Article 311(2)(b) of the Constitution, which permits dispensing with a departmental inquiry where holding such an inquiry is not reasonably practicable.

However, the High Court found that the State had failed to establish the exceptional circumstances necessary to justify dispensing with the inquiry. There was no adequate material demonstrating that the complainant or witnesses had been threatened, intimidated or prevented from participating in the proceedings.

The Court held that the seriousness of an allegation cannot, by itself, justify bypassing the constitutional requirement of a departmental inquiry.

Reinstatement Ordered, but Regular Inquiry Permitted

Consequently, the High Court quashed the dismissal order and the subsequent appellate order and directed the State Government to reinstate the petitioner forthwith. The State was, however, permitted to initiate and conduct a regular departmental inquiry in accordance with applicable service rules.

The Court clarified that it had expressed no opinion on the merits of the allegations against the officer. The question of back wages was also left to be determined in accordance with the outcome of any subsequent departmental inquiry.

Legal Significance

The decision highlights two important legal principles: the constitutional protection available to public servants against arbitrary dismissal and the professional responsibility of advocates and government legal departments to verify judicial authorities before relying on them in court.

While AI tools can assist legal research and drafting, their outputs cannot replace independent verification of judgments, citations and legal propositions. The ruling serves as an important reminder that accountability for pleadings filed before courts ultimately rests with the legal professionals and authorities placing them on record.