The Calcutta High Court has dismissed a challenge brought by tenants against their eviction, holding that prior written permission from the landlord is mandatory before subletting rented commercial premises. The Court clarified that fulfilling financial conditions under a tenancy agreement does not replace the requirement of obtaining written consent.
A Division Bench comprising Justice Shabbar Rashidi and Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya delivered the order on November 12, 2026.
Background of the Dispute
The dispute concerned a commercial shop room rented under a tenancy agreement that permitted subletting subject to certain conditions. Under the agreement, the tenants were required to pay the landlord 10 per cent of any salami received from a sub-tenant exceeding the initial ₹25,000.
However, the agreement separately stipulated that the premises could not be sublet without the landlord's prior written permission.
The tenants subsequently sublet the commercial premises and tendered the agreed share of the salami. However, they had not obtained the landlord's prior written consent. The landlord objected to the subletting, resulting in eviction proceedings.
The tenants challenged the dismissal of their plea before the Calcutta High Court.
High Court's Observations
The Division Bench examined the relevant clauses of the tenancy agreement together rather than interpreting the financial and permission-related conditions independently.
The Court observed that obtaining prior written consent remained mandatory under the agreement, irrespective of the financial arrangements between the parties.
The Bench clarified that payment of the agreed share of the salami could not substitute compliance with the separate requirement of obtaining written permission before subletting the premises.
Since the tenants had admittedly failed to secure the landlord's prior written consent, the Court upheld the interpretation adopted by the trial court and the first appellate court and dismissed the tenants' challenge.
Legal Significance of the Ruling
The ruling highlights the importance of complying with contractual conditions governing subletting. It reinforces the distinction between financial obligations under a tenancy agreement and the separate requirement to obtain the landlord's prior written permission.
For commercial tenants, the decision serves as a reminder that subletting without following the prescribed consent procedure may expose them to eviction proceedings.
Key Takeaway
Tenants should carefully examine their tenancy agreements and obtain written permission from landlords before subletting commercial premises whenever such consent is contractually required. Payment of additional charges or an agreed financial share does not automatically authorise subletting.
Source: The Indian Express | November 18, 2026